If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
Shonen Jump says too many manga creators are trying to impress readers instead of entertaining them
The surprising blunt advice a Shonen Jump editor is giving manga creators.
NewsbyChris Arrant, Editor-in-Chief
Published on Thu Jul 16 2026
Popverse’s top stories
- When Daredevil was at Netflix, Charlie Cox felt it was Marvel Studios’ “unwanted stepchild”
- James Gunn’s DC Universe already has one eager Poison Ivy candidate: Marisha Ray of Critical Role
- The ’80s TMNT cartoon was far less serious and far more funny than the original comics, and co-creator Kevin Eastman loves it for that reason
Manga publishers are actively looking for their next big star creators, and several major publishers are currently doing global contests to find them, even outside of Japan. Shueisha is one of the largest manga publishers in the world, running the Shonen Jump brand and co-owning VIZ Media here in the United States. It has a very active account on X (formerly known as Twitter) under the name Jump Manga Award, with its Shonen Jump editors anonymously answering questions from aspiring manga creators as a means to build awareness for its various submission contests. It’s an active community, and back in February, a question about creating manga brought out a surprisingly blunt response from these anonymous Shonen Jump editors.
It started with a simple question, asking ‘What does it truly mean to face your audience?’ The term ‘face your audience’ is a common phrase in manga, and particularly in critiques of manga submission portfolios by Shonen Jump editors.
“We believe the difference lies in whether the author is drawing‘simply’ for their own self-indulgence, or with the intention of entertaining the readers burned into their minds,” reads the anonymous response from a Shonen Jump editor. “You could say it’s like being obsessed with ‘being unpredictable’ while completely making light of ‘not disappointing your readers.'”
That being said, the anonymous Shonen Jump editor is aware (and warns!) that being too “reader-oriented” is pandering, and could lead to the author not imbuing their stories with what makes it unique to the manga creator.
“However, if that self-indulgence goes out of control, with an overbearing ‘Just you watch!’ mentality – a twist that’s never been done before and surprises the readers (in a negative way), sadly boils down to your work not being on the same page as the audience,” the Shonen Jump anonymous editor continues. “The ideal is to overcome both the readers’ predictions and expectations, but from the perspective of manga being a commercial work, we get the impression that ‘If you’re going to betray readers’ expectations, at least don’t be unpredictable’ is something you hear very often. But this is only a personal opinion, and other people may have a different understanding of this.”
Who that person is to have that personal opinion is not known, but it’s endorsed by Shueisha and Shonen Jump enough to circulate it on one of their official platforms.
Each week, Popverse’s resident anime expert Trent Cannon runs down the latest and, dare we say “greatest,” in anime and manga in Popverse Jump. Some recent columns have included…
- Aggretsuko vs Chainsaw Man: Two Wildly different anine with the same anti-capitalist message
- The Summer Anime season return of Kaiju No. 8, Sakamoto Days, & Dan Da Dan are forcing me to break my vow of watching less anime
- From Tomo-Chan to Oshi No Ko: How some of your favorite manga creators got their start in hentai
- Piracy is baked into anime’s past, but, like Crunchyroll, we should move on from it
- Flying whales, mechs, and Miyazaki vibes: Inside Netflix’s Leviathan anime with the people who made it
- How AI translations of manga continues the ‘enshitification’ of the medium, and why Japanese publishers are “less precious” about it
- I never wanted a Cyberpunk Edgerunners sequel, but God help me I’m going to watch it
- The Summer Hikaru Died delivers its cosmic horror at an agonizingly slow pace
- The one thing that Dan Da Dan does better than Demon Slayer ever did
- Studio Ghibli movies have never been as cozy as you think they are and that’s what makes them magic
Follow Popverse for upcoming event coverage and news
Chris Arrant: Chris Arrant is the Popverse’s Editor-in-Chief. He has written about pop culture for USA Today, Life, Entertainment Weekly, Publisher’s Weekly, Marvel, Newsarama, CBR, and more. He has acted as a judge for the Will Eisner Comic Industry Awards, the Harvey Awards, and the Stan Lee Awards. (He/him)
Let Popverse be your tour guide through the wilderness of pop culture
Sign in and let us help you find your new favorite thing.
