Over the years, <a href="https://www.si.com/collectibles/news/1965-topps-football-a-part-of-hobby-history” rel=”nofollow noopener” target=”_blank”>the Football hobby has seen many iconic sets released. For some collectors, it can be tough to determine which set has greater eye appeal, nostalgia factor, and overall value. While there is not one certain set of criteria to make this determination, one characteristic of a set stays constant: the contents. Sets that contain key rookie cards always demand attention in the hobby, and this trend started all the way back in the 1950’s.
On that note, let’s start the journey through the decades to look at the most iconic Football sets ever released in the hobby.
6. 1958 Topps Football
Key Cards:Johnny Unitas – Card #22, Jim Brown – RC, Card #62, Sonny Jurgensen – RC, Card #90
Rationale: The 1958 setmight not be the most visually appealing of the decade, but it has a few cards that stand out. Most notably, Jim Brown’s rookie card can be found in the set, and it still sells for a good amount of money in the hobby today. High-grade copies can fetch thousands, if not tens of thousands of dollars. The set also features Sonny Jurgensen’s rookie – he might not be well known in today’s hobby, but he is a legend in the Washington DC area. In a decade with iconic designs, the 1958 set was not going to climb too high on this list.
5. 1951 Bowman Football
Key Cards:Otto Graham – Card #2, Norm Van Brocklin – RC, Card #4, Tom Landry – RC, Card #20
Rationale: Some collectors might forget that Bowman did release Football sets during this time, with some coming out before Topps obtained the license. The 1951 set is simple in its design, which is why it has held up over time. Visually, the set is able to bring out a sense of nostalgia and has strong eye appeal. The standout rookie from the set is legendary coach Tom Landry, which features him throwing a pass. A PSA 4 sold recently for $300, showing that there is still interest in the set. It can be a tough one to put together, especially in good shape.
4. 1956 Topps Football
Key Cards:Roosevelt Brown – RC, Card #41, Lenny Moore – RC, Card #60, Bobby Layne – Card #116
Rationale: The 1956 set is the first to feature the football license on Topps’ end and is currently used in their NFL Living Set design. Major rookies in the set include Roosevelt Brown and Lenny Moore, but the set is infamous for being the first in a long line of Topps Football releases, which bumps it up the list. Similar to other releases featured, high-grade copies from the set are difficult to obtain.
3. 1955 Topps All American Football
Key Cards:Knute Rockne – Card #16, Jim Thorpe – Card #37, The Four Horseman – Card #68
Rationale: The 1955 All-American release features 100 collegiate stars, with some major names making the checklist. Players such as Jim Thorpe, Sammy Baugh, and the Four Horsemen from Notre Dame are highlights, along with coach Knute Rockne. The design of the set is very American-themed, with the colors red, white, and blue featured heavily in the design. The Thorpe and Rockne cards are the most coveted from the set, selling in PSA 4 condition at $500 and $250, respectively.
2. 1950 Bowman Football
Key Cards:Doak Walker – RC, Card #1, Marion Motley – RC, Card #43, Otto Graham – RC, Card #45, Sammy Baugh – Card #100
Rationale: The 1950 Bowman Football set is unique in the sense that the cards are not standard size – they are small and square-shaped. This immediately puts a premium on the cards in good condition, but also makes the set stand out in the context of the decade. Once color is added to the card, it makes for an immediate hit in the hobby. The set includes many top rookies, but Otto Graham’s is the most desirable. An off-condition, ungraded copy of the card sold recently for $364.
1. 1957 Topps Football
Key Cards:Bart Starr – RC, Card #119, Johnny Unitas – RC, Card #138, Paul Hornung – RC, Card #151
Rationale: The top spot on the list goes to the 1957 Topps Football set due to the star power contained in its rookie cards. “The Big Three” of Starr, Unitas, and Hornung can take many years to acquire for set builders, even more so when high-grade copies are involved. Even as time has gone on, collectors are still seeking to add these cards to their collection. For this reason, it earns the spot as the most iconic set of the 1950’s in the Football hobby.
While many sets were released in the 1950’s, these six stand out above the rest. Both Bowman and Topps releases have strong checklists, with many key rookie cards for collectors to chase after. Regardles of which of these sets a collector prefers, any card from these sets would be a great addition to a collection.
Today’s best reads
-
Topps Offers Update on 2026 Topps Chrome Cosmic Production Error
-
Tom Brady Signed Exclusive Topps Now Card on Packers-Patriots FOX Broadcast
This article was originally published on www.si.com/collectibles as The 6 Most Iconic Football Card Sets of the 1950’s.
