Sony has defeated a claim brought for 12.2 million consumers after the CAT rejected allegations that its closed PlayStation store kept prices unfairly high.
Businesses defending competition claims over closed digital platforms, where the operator controls how users buy and access content, have been handed a substantial victory after the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) dismissed a £2 billion class-action claim against Sony. The tribunal found that competition between gaming systems constrained what it could charge PlayStation customers.
In a unanimous decision delivered this morning (17 November) by a panel chaired by Ben Tidswell, the tribunal rejected allegations that Sony had unlawfully excluded rival distributors and charged excessive prices.
“We are disappointed by the tribunal’s judgment,” said class representative Alex Neill in a statement emailed to ICLG News. She continued: “This case has been five years in the making and raised important questions on behalf of 12 million UK consumers. We argued that PlayStation users were being overcharged for digital games and add-on content because they were effectively locked into Sony’s digital ecosystem.”
The background
Alex Neill’s representative company brought proceedings on behalf of approximately 12.2 million consumers who bought digital PlayStation games or additional content in the UK. It filed the claim in August 2022, initially valued at up to £5 billion, securing certification in November 2023. The trial ran from 10 March to 8 May 2026, with the claim backed by Woodsford and Neill’s legal advisers working under conditional fee agreements.
Digital purchases go through the PlayStation Store, where Sony generally targets a margin of approximately 30% on third-party sales. Game revenue helps subsidise the manufacture of gaming consoles.
The class representative alleged breaches of section 18 of the Competition Act 1998 and, before 31 December 2020, article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which prohibit abuse of a dominant market position. It sought approximately £1.49 billion in damages, rising to £1.971 billion with interest.
The arguments
The representative argued that Sony dominated digital PlayStation distribution, leaving consumers with nowhere else to buy games and add-on content. Requiring purchases through its store, tying that store to the console and refusing competing distributors access allegedly denied users competition and choice. The class representative also challenged Sony’s prices and margins as excessive and unfair, arguing that consumers would have paid approximately 20% less without the alleged abuses.
Sony said this overlooked competition between gaming systems and the role of game revenue in financing consoles. Moreover, opening PlayStation to rival stores would also require expensive technical changes that could compromise security and affect performance.
The decision
The tribunal agreed that digital PlayStation sales could not be considered in isolation. Consumers could also buy physical games, while competition between gaming systems helped keep Sony’s prices in check. Accepting that Sony and other suppliers used game revenue to subsidise consoles, the tribunal concluded that “competition and rivalry at the system level do provide an effective means to regulate pricing and competitive conduct in the aftermarket”.
That finding defeated the basis of the claim. The representative had not put forward an alternative case that Sony had abused a dominant position in a wider market encompassing competing gaming systems. Counsel therefore accepted that the claim could not succeed.
Responding to that reasoning, Neill said: “The tribunal has taken a different view, finding that consumers had the option of buying physical games and could anticipate their spending on games and additional content over the lifetime of a console when deciding which console to purchase.”
The tribunal nevertheless examined the remaining allegations in case its findings concerning the gaming market were overturned on appeal. None succeeded.
It drew a clear distinction between this case and Kent v Apple [2025]. Allowing a third-party app store on to Apple’s platform required little adaptation, whereas opening PlayStation to competing stores would require substantial technical changes, with unresolved security and performance problems.
The stricter Bronner requirements, governing when businesses must give rivals access to infrastructure reserved for their own use, therefore applied. Those requirements were not met, partly because the representative had not clearly established that anyone had ever actually asked to operate a competing distribution service on PlayStation.
The excessive-pricing allegation also failed. Applying United Brands and subsequent authorities, the tribunal considered whether Sony’s margin was excessive and unfair. That assessment had to account for the game revenue used to subsidise console production. The representative had not established that the margin was excessive or, even if it were, unfair.
Neill’s statement concluded: “We believe these were important issues to test on behalf of consumers, and we are now carefully considering the judgment and our options, including whether to appeal this first-instance decision.”
Costs and any applications for permission to appeal will be considered in the week commencing 14 December 2026.
The parties
In Alex Neill Class Representative Ltd (class representative) v Sony Interactive <a href="https://comicvibe.com/grand-theft-auto-vi-could-be-the-biggest-entertainment-launch-in-history/” title=”‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ could be the biggest entertainment launch in history”>Entertainment Europe and another (defendants), the class representative was represented by Robert Palmer KC of Monckton Chambers, instructed by Milberg London. The defendants were represented by Daniel Beard KC of Monckton Chambers, instructed by Linklaters.
