- News
- World News
- UK News
- British sisters lose £90 million legal battle against LOL Surprise maker MGA Entertainment after court rejects their claim over alleged threats to major UK toy retailers stocking rival Worldeez toys
Trending
Jensen Huang
Chris Van Hollen
Spain Protest
Pakistan Accident
British sisters lose £90 million legal battle against LOL Surprise maker MGA Entertainment after court rejects their claim over alleged threats to major UK toy retailers stocking rival Worldeez toys
![]()
Image AI generated
Two British sisters have lost a major court battle against US toy giant MGA Entertainment after seeking up to £90 million in damages over claims that the company deliberately sabotaged their collectable toy brand, Worldeez. Hayley Michaelson and Lauren Cohen alleged that MGA threatened to withdraw its popular LOL Surprise products from major UK retailers if they stocked their competing toy. Although the High Court previously found that MGA had engaged in an unlawful campaign to exclude Worldeez from the market, it refused to award compensation, ruling that the business would not have traded profitably anyway. The Court of Appeal has now dismissed the sisters’ challenge.
How did the British sisters come up with the idea for Worldeez toys
The idea for Worldeez emerged during a family holiday in 2014, when sisters Hayley Michaelson and Lauren Cohen, alongside their husbands Marc Michaelson and Johnny Cohen, discussed creating a collectable toy inspired by children’s interest in unboxing videos and surprise toys.The product was designed as a globe-shaped capsule containing country-themed collectables. Its initial range covered eight countries, including the UK, France, Italy, Brazil, India, Egypt, Japan and the US, with 15 figurines for each country. The business secured investment and planned to distribute the toys through major retailers Smyths, Toys ‘R’ Us and The Entertainer.
How did the Worldeez toy brand lose major UK retail deals
According to evidence presented during the appeal, Cabo’s barrister Stefan Kupper said MGA began its campaign on 23 May 2017, after seeing a YouTube video featuring child influencer Tiana promoting Worldeez. He alleged that the company threatened to withhold supplies of its popular LOL Surprise collectables from retailers that agreed to stock the competing product.The allegations also included claims that MGA repeatedly described Worldeez as a ‘knock-off’ and threatened legal action over alleged intellectual property and patent infringement. According to Mr Kupper, The Entertainer subsequently cancelled an order it had placed, while Smyths and Toys ‘R’ Us did not proceed with orders. Worldeez eventually reached the market through discount retailer B&M, but its initial sales declined.
Why did the judge refuse to award damages to the Worldeez founders
Cabo previously brought the dispute before the High Court, where Mrs Justice Bacon found that MGA had used coercive tactics against three major UK toy retailers as part of an overall campaign to exclude Worldeez. The judge concluded that the threats to withdraw LOL Surprise supplies, alongside the legal threats and allegations of imitation, amounted to an abuse of a dominant market position.However, the judge refused to award damages, finding that Cabo would not have traded profitably even without MGA’s conduct. She acknowledged that Worldeez was an appealing product with an initially successful online marketing campaign, but said it was competing in a crowded collectables market and needed more than that to succeed.
What arguments did both sides present in the Worldeez Court of Appeal battle
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
Cabo subsequently appealed the decision, arguing that the High Court had placed an unfair burden on a start-up business by requiring it to demonstrate that it would have been profitable in circumstances where its launch had allegedly been prevented. Mr Kupper argued that the company’s lost opportunity to secure distribution through major retailers had caused it harm.Representing MGA, barrister Victoria Wakefield KC disputed the appeal, arguing that Cabo was seeking to establish an open-ended damages award despite the finding that it would not have been profitable in the alternative circumstances. She also challenged the company’s original claim of up to £90 million. Following a two-day hearing in London, Lord Justice Males, Lord Justice Popplewell and Lord Justice Phillips dismissed Cabo’s appeal. The judges said their reasons for the decision would be provided at a later date.
You use AI every day. Now get your AI Quotient. Take the AIQ test.
End of Article
Follow Us On Social Media