Rabbit Hole Auctions is leaning into a different kind of vintage sale for its second event, pairing recognizable sports-card stars with a broad mix of historical collectibles, tobacco-era material, autographed memorabilia, and offbeat hobby items that rarely sit side by side in the same catalog.
The auction opened October 11 and runs through November 1, with roughly 170 lots available. While names such as Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Jackie Robinson, Willie Mays, Ted Williams, Sandy Koufax, and Wayne Gretzky help headline the event, the larger identity of the sale is its range. Collectors browsing the catalog will find baseball cards and hockey rookies, but also boxing cards, actor and actress cards, fish-themed tobacco issues, horse-racing cards, entertainment pieces, and historical advertising.
That broad curation reflects the vision of founder Justin Hirsch, who has positioned Rabbit Hole Auctions as a boutique venue focused on vintage material, manageable catalogs, and a collecting experience built around discovery as much as marquee names.
A Boutique Auction Model Built Around Attainable Vintage
Hirsch’s collecting background stretches back decades. His first auction experience came in 1982, when he attended with his father and brought home two rookie cards: a 1966 Topps Jim Palmer and a 1969 Topps Reggie Jackson. Those cards remain part of his collection, and that early connection to the hobby still shapes the direction of the auction house.
For more collector background, read Football Card Market Shows Sharp Weekly Swings as Dealers See Fast Sales and Vintage Value Gaps.
Over time, his collecting evolved beyond childhood accumulation into a more deliberate pursuit of vintage pieces. Business travel reportedly led him to seek cards tied to the cities he visited, and a pandemic-era rediscovery of 1955 Bowman cards pushed him toward building that set. Eventually, that long-running interest in cards and memorabilia developed into Rabbit Hole Auctions.
Rather than trying to mirror the largest auction houses in the category, Rabbit Hole has focused on a smaller, more curated format. The idea is to create a sale that collectors can reasonably explore from top to bottom instead of only targeting a few headline lots and skipping the rest. That approach also gives unusual items room to stand alongside more familiar vintage cards.
The company describes much of its material in the range of attainable vintage, with many pieces intended to stay approachable for a broad group of bidders even as select premium items anchor the catalog.
For another perspective on this story, read Rabbit Hole Auctions’ 170-Lot Sale Puts Vintage Cards, Autographs and Oddities in the Same Room.
Key Sports Card and Memorabilia Highlights in the Sale
Traditional sports collectors still have plenty to chase in the current auction. Several lots stand out immediately for player recognition, era, or presentation.
One of the most distinctive pieces is a vintage 1956 Topps baseball card machine display featuring six Hall of Famers. Among the players visible are Willie Mays, Ted Williams, Sandy Koufax, and Yogi Berra. The display was further enhanced after Hirsch acquired a group of roughly 50 raw 1956 Topps cards and paired them with the machine, turning the lot into more than a standard single-card offering.
There is also strong interest likely around an autographed 1960s Type 1 original vintage photo showing Mickey Mantle and Roy Sievers, with Mantle having signed and inscribed the piece. Signed vintage baseball photography with clear player appeal tends to cross over between card collectors and memorabilia-focused bidders, giving that lot broader reach within the hobby.
Among individual cards, the catalog includes a 1954 Topps Hank Aaron, a 1955 Topps Jackie Robinson #50 in PSA 4 Very Good-Excellent, and a 1979 O-Pee-Chee Wayne Gretzky rookie. Those names alone span multiple generations of collectors and bring together three of the hobby’s most durable markets: postwar baseball stars, iconic Hall of Fame cardboard, and a premier hockey rookie issue.
T206 tobacco cards also appear throughout the sale, maintaining the auction’s vintage foundation. Prewar tobacco issues continue to attract veteran collectors because of their historic place in the hobby and the near-endless variety available through backs, subjects, conditions, and related type collecting opportunities.
The Barry Walner Collection Adds a Personal Vintage Touch
One of the more compelling sections of the auction comes from the Barry Walner Collection. The group features autographed Baseball Magazine player photos that were originally signed through the mail in the early 1950s. Rather than dispersing or losing the material over time, Walner preserved the signatures in a scrapbook for decades.
For the current sale, the pieces were removed and submitted to PSA for authentication and encapsulation. The result is a group that carries both autograph appeal and a strong story of long-term preservation. Players represented include Warren Spahn, Ralph Kiner, and Herb Score, among others.
Autograph collectors often respond to material like this because it sits at the intersection of baseball history and hobby provenance. Signed photo pieces from the period are not simply about the autograph itself. They also speak to a collecting era when fans reached athletes directly by mail, creating personal connections that later became hobby artifacts in their own right.
That kind of lot also aligns closely with the auction house’s emphasis on storytelling. In this case, the story is not manufactured around hype or scarcity language. It comes from the documented survival of the material and the participation of the original collector in helping describe it for the sale.
Why the Non-Sports and Historical Material Matters
What truly separates this auction from a standard vintage sports event is the volume of non-traditional material mixed into the lineup. Rabbit Hole is not treating those items like novelty add-ons. They are a central part of the catalog’s identity.
Among the unusual offerings are 178 nineteenth-century actors and actresses cards, early 1910 to 1912 boxing cards, a nine-card lot from the 1910 T206 Fish Series, and five 1889 Kinney Bros. N230 Famous English Running Horses cards. For type collectors and hobby historians, those categories can be just as interesting as mainstream baseball singles.
The T206 Fish Series is especially notable because it connects directly to the broader tobacco-card tradition that many sports collectors already know through baseball. Similarly, the Kinney Bros. horse-racing cards fit well with the long-standing collector appetite for nineteenth-century cardboard that extends beyond the major American team sports.
Modern Allen & Ginter collectors may find those lots particularly appealing. The appeal of Allen & Ginter has always included its willingness to feature more than athletes, and these older issues tap into that same spirit of eclectic subject matter. Animals, performers, and historical oddities were part of early card culture long before multi-subject modern products made that format feel fresh again.
That matters because it broadens the audience for the sale. A bidder might arrive looking for a classic baseball card and end up discovering a niche category they had never seriously considered before. For a boutique auction house, that sort of crossover can be more valuable long term than filling every page with the same familiar names and formats.
Additional Lots Expand the Catalog Beyond Baseball
The catalog also includes a group of 1970-71 basketball cards from the estate of Priscilla Reetz. In a detail that fits the auction’s more personal style, her children contributed to the lot descriptions as a tribute to their mother. That gives the group meaning beyond checklist value and condition, especially for bidders who appreciate family provenance and hobby continuity.
Collectors will also find a complete 1966 Batman Red set in a custom binder, which adds another lane for vintage non-sports enthusiasts. Material like that helps position the sale as a destination for collectors who move across categories rather than staying limited to one sport or era.
Another unusually personal entry is Yummy Up Bakery, a children’s book written by Hirsch’s daughter when she was 10 and later published when she was 16. Now 22, she sees the book return as a lot after it reportedly drew interest in the company’s inaugural sale. It is not a traditional hobby headline piece, but it reinforces the auction house’s willingness to include items that carry personal and narrative value alongside recognized vintage cards.
Notable Items and Categories in the Auction
- 1956 Topps baseball card machine display with six Hall of Famers
- 1960s Type 1 original vintage photo of Mickey Mantle and Roy Sievers, signed and inscribed by Mantle
- 1954 Topps Hank Aaron
- 1955 Topps Jackie Robinson #50 PSA 4 Very Good-Excellent
- 1979 O-Pee-Chee Wayne Gretzky rookie
- Multiple T206 tobacco cards
- Barry Walner Collection autographed Baseball Magazine player photos
- 178 nineteenth-century actors and actresses cards
- Early 1910-12 boxing cards
- 1910 T206 Fish Series nine-card lot
- 1889 Kinney Bros. N230 Famous English Running Horses cards
- 1970-71 basketball cards from the estate of Priscilla Reetz
- 1966 Batman Red complete set in custom binder
How Rabbit Hole Auctions Is Positioning Itself in the Hobby
Rabbit Hole’s first sale took place in 2025, and the second auction appears to continue the same strategy: smaller catalogs, broad vintage coverage, and price points aimed at keeping participation realistic for more than just high-end buyers. The company has indicated that much of its material typically falls in an approximate range from $10 to $3,000, even if certain lots sit above the everyday entry point.
That pricing philosophy matters in a hobby environment where many auction headlines revolve around record-setting cards, elite rarities, and seven-figure valuations. There is still strong demand for that level of material, but there is also a healthy market for curated auctions where a collector can chase history, variety, and character without needing a blue-chip budget.
In that sense, Rabbit Hole is chasing a lane that feels increasingly relevant. Collectors continue to value major stars and iconic issues, but many also want sales that are enjoyable to browse, educational in their mix of material, and open to impulse discoveries. A catalog that blends a Gretzky rookie, T206 cards, signed baseball photos, nineteenth-century actors cards, and a Batman set creates a browsing experience that feels closer to old-school collecting than purely investment-driven selling.
The current sale closes November 1, and the catalog offers a clear view of how Rabbit Hole wants to operate in the vintage space: with a smaller footprint, a broad historical lens, and enough range to make discovery part of the auction itself.
Photo Gallery
