Earlier this year, Hallmark celebrated 25 years. A milestone that inspired some celebration during the summer months and now, Christmas movie season is fully in swing and so it would seem ideal to look back at all of the favorite Christmas movies from those 25 years. I published a list of favorite Hallmark rom-coms, but excluded the seasonal titles.
LIST |THE BEST AND WORST TV SHOWS OF 2026 – RANKED!
Now that many have decked halls and hung the mistletoe, before the year of Hallmark 25 ends, let’s dig into the research of finding all the many (many) titles that have released over 25 years. I’m discovering that a lot of my pulls are new, by comparison, but I think this is fair since I think overall, the production from the network has noticeably improved in more recent years. So let’s settle in and see what there is to discover.
TEN of the MOST FAVORITE CHRISTMAS MOVIES from HALLMARK 25 years
listed, in no particular order, from a – z
A SEASON ofPROMIES, 2026
This film is different than anything I have seen from Hallmark Christmas in, well, a while. It’s a little bittersweet, so I don’t think it will be a fan (who tend to love the happy movies) favorite, but this film has value. It also has a fabulous cast (James Denton, Ali Liebert, Brooke D’Orsay), too. There isn’t anyone I didn’t like.

As someone who loves a happy Christmas TV rom-com, even I can admit to how good this is. The focus is on family working through difficult emotional barriers, but what this film does in the romance is just inexplicably good. Everything works and though I don’t want every Christmas movie to be this, there is 100% a place for titles like this in each slate.
AN UNEXPECTED CHRISTMAS, 2021
Don’t judge me (please), but I cannot remember a great deal about this film other than it has Tyler Hynes. Does this mean I shouldn’t include it here? Perhaps, but I also remember being impressedby this one in relation to its premiere year peers. The film was about pretending to date, so yes, a very normal concept, but it has personality which was likely in part to it fitting Hynes well. Of course, the addition of Bethany Joy Lenz always great in her roles is a plus, too!
Highest Rated Premiere of 2021: Christmas at Castle Hart
CHRISTMAS at the GOLDEN DRAGON, 2022
Adding this one is surprising me because the year it aired, I didn’t anticipate loving it the way I did. This title, which is a kind of vignette collection of stories, is full of warmth, charm and pure joy. The cast is also fabulous and consists of lesser used co-leads, and yes, we allknow how much I love this. In my experience it adds to the uniqueness of a film.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2022: Three Wise Men and a Baby
HANUKKAH on the ROCKS, 2024
Though a title I only saw once, I remember being unusually impressed with this one. And it was also something I didn’t expect to love in the way I did. I like that many scenes take place in a bar which is an unusual locale that adds a new energy. Beyond this, the story is sweet and more authentic, perhaps helped by the fact that the roles aren’t played by frequent network leads.

HOLIDAY CRASHERS, 2024
This was the first (if I remember right) film I saw of 2024, and it was extremely delightful and quite unique for the line up in the year. It’s even one I rewatched in 2024 and would watch again now. It’s a fun film about best friends who, as the title reveals, end up crashing parties and learn about themselves and of course, find some romance, too. All of it is delightfully and festively fun.

Highest Rated Premiere of 2024: Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story
HOLIDAY HOTLINE, 2023
Delightful in ways I never anticipated (there seems to be a theme with my picks!), this one has Niall Matter playing an architect who meets a woman trying to decide what she wants next in life. There is just something about this film that is impossible not to like. The acting, with Emily Tennant in the co-lead role, helps Holiday Hotline with authenticity and is easy watching. Leaning a little more bittersweet in places, it’s ultimately still cheery and charming.

Highest Rated Premiere of 2023: A Very Scottish Christmas
ON the 12th DATE of CHRISTMAS, 2020
This one stood out as clever and fun in the pack of 2020 premieres. It had Tyler Hynes and Mallory Jansen in a story about creatively different app designers who set out on a scavenger hunt hoping it leads to a creative breakthrough.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2020: If Only I Had Christmas
SINGLE on the 25th, 2025
I still cannot put my finger on what it is I loved about this title, but I did. It’s different and entertaining, and the ending is sweetly swoony but still true to everything that comes first. It’s a story about single people who decide to spend Christmas together apart as the social season sends them to various different events.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2025: The More the Merrier
SNOW BRIDE, 2013
A title from way back in 2013! I didn’t include a lot of films from the beginning, but this title is as sweetly silly as it is traditional. To be honest, I don’t remember the specifics, but one thing I’m sure of is that this one is cuute. The plot has a kind of cutesy faux dating trope that lead Katrina Law accidentally falls into… while wearing a wedding gown!
Needless to say, I’m long overdue for a re-watch and though it is over ten years old, it’s one that deserves a little more love. So, I should make it happen this year yet.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2013: A Very Merry Mix-Up
THE 5-YEAR CHRISTMAS PARTY, 2024
Jordan Fisher and Katie Findlay star in this and their on-screen partnership is sweet. There’s a strong sense of friendship and how the love story evolves is mostly sweet. The gist of the script follows two friends who meet up every year after working for the same catering company during the season.
THE CHRISTMAS CHARADE, 2024
Easily a more ambitious project from its premiere year, The Christmas Charade fumbles a bit (sometimes toomuch). However, I admire that it tries to do something “bigger” than most of its peers. It’s a kind of spy caper movie that seems to have a lot of fun with its concept. The mistaken blind date meet-cute is also impossibly cute. Overall, this is something that may remind you of a film like Knight and Day on a smaller (and festive!) scale.

THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME of theYEAR, 2008
This is an oldie, but it’s one of the rareHallmark titles I’ve seen multipletimes. It follows a man who arrives to visit his beloved niece and her son for the Christmas season. Much to the annoyance of his overly organized niece, he brings home a stranded airport passenger who, naturally, she ends up catching a crush on. The film is led by a big name in Henry Winkler.
THE NIGHTS BEFORE CHRISTMAS, 2026
One that justmade its debut, The Nights Before Christmas is easily one of the more ambitious titles from Hallmark. The way its filmed, and produced is part of this, but also helping is Tyler Hynes in this role which suits him well.

The meet-cutes (yes, plural) are also darling in a script that explores the idea of a time loop (and asks interesting questions about the reality and gift of time passing). It also, surprisingly, does maintain a cheerful demeanor.
WE MET in DECEMBER, 2025
Charming in ways we don’t usually see from Hallmark, Autumn Reeser and Niall Matter lead this one about two people who meet after delayed flights. Then after spending a magical night together, they end up being unable to contact each other. From there, the story follows their respective lives and the idea that maybe they can reconnect.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2025: The More the Merrier
WHERE ARE YOU, CHRISTMAS?, 2023
This one was ambitious for Hallmark and went black-and-white as a way to show a world devoid of Christmas charm. The set up is about a woman frustrated with all the trappings who wishes Christmas would vanish. The film has a kind of It’s a Wonderful Life feeling without being some ambitious remake or reimagining, which I appreciate.
Highest Rated Premiere of 2023: A Very Scottish Christmas
…and yes, I may update this list yet this year depending on how many of the 2026 titles I like! There is still one or two I’m hoping is good.
HONORABLE MENTIONS
- A BILTMORE CHRISTMAS
- CHRISTMAS with theSINGHS
- HOLIDAY TOUCHDOWN [TRIO] these are just sweet, and definitely more ambitious for the network
- IT’S CHRISTMAS, EVE
- THREE WISE MEN and aBABY
PURE NOSTALGIA PICKS
- A Boyfriend for Christmas because I’ve watched this so many times over the years, and it was one of the first Christmas movies from Hallmark I fell for
- A Princess for Christmas this was essentially the first ‘royal’ romance for the network, and it’s sweet plus has a surprisingly excellent cast
See all of the above titles with Hallmark+
HIGHEST RATED CHRISTMAS MOVIE PREMIERES
Just for fun, here is also a list of the ten highest rated (these numbers are what has been reported) premieres over the years. As is the normal reality, most of these aren’t among my most favorites, which is always interesting to me.
- CHRISTMAS UNDER WRAPS, 2014
- SWITCHED for CHRISTMAS, 2017
- THE CHRISTMAS TRAIN, 2017
- JOURNEY BACK to CHRISTMAS, 2016
- A CHRISTMAS DETOUR, 2015
- CHRISTMAS at GRACELAND, 2018
- MY CHRISTMAS LOVE, 2016
- THE CHRISTMAS COTTAGE, 2017
- A ROYAL CHRISTMAS, 2014
- MY CHRISTMAS DREAM, 2016
Ok, let’s hear from you all! Which movies from Hallmark’s 26 years set during Christmas did you enjoy? Which ones would you add? Do you have a list of your favorites? Share all of your thoughts down below!
BROWSE even more
- ‘MISTLETOE MURDERS,’ SEASON THREE: MORE NEW CLUES IN THIS CLEVER AND MERRY SHOW
- THE BEST AND SILLIEST CHRISTMAS MOVIE SCENES OF WEEKEND FOUR!
Thanks for visiting; return again soon.
About Rissi JC
amateur graphic designer. confirmed bookaholic. bubbl’r enthusiast. critical thinker. miswesterner. social media coordinator. writer.