Television
How creators are adapting to the changing television landscape
- Download
- Embed
<iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/nx-s1-6042512/nx-s1-10013058" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player"> - Transcript
Last week at a rental car counter, I recalled an episode of “Seinfeld” about the rental car agent who knows how to take the reservation but not how to hold the reservation, which is the most important part. The show still seems relevant. But it’s also old, which is true of many popular sitcoms. Our Planet Money colleagues Ricky Mulvey and Wailin Wong asked why producers are making fewer new sitcoms.
WAILIN WONG, BYLINE: Sitcoms are still really popular in America, but there’s just one problem. Many of them ended their runs over a decade ago.
RICKY MULVEY, BYLINE: In the 1990s, sitcoms made up about 12% of new shows. It’s less than 2% in the 2020s.
WONG: Sitcoms, if they do well, have this long tale of success. So we wanted to find out, why aren’t streamers trying to make more of these shows? What happened?
MIKE SCHUR: Settle in, people. There’s a couple of things going on here.
MULVEY: Mike Schur has a new show coming out on NBC’s streaming service, Peacock. It’s called “Dig,” starring Amy Poehler. In addition, he produced and wrote on the U.S. version of “The Office” and created “The Good Place.”
WONG: Mike says the economics fundamentally changed. In the old days, many successful sitcoms actually lost money for networks when episodes premiered. Ad revenue on the first airing did not make up for production costs, like paying the stars.
SCHUR: But you don’t mind because there’s a flourishing aftermarket. You’re going to package them and sell them into syndication.
MULVEY: Syndication is when reruns of a show run on other channels. When cable was booming, this allowed less-watched channels to fill their content engines and gave the popular networks more cash.
WONG: Now networks aren’t selling to those smaller channels as much. They’re selling to streamers. Mike says these deals last a long time and mean less money coming in.
MULVEY: That’s because when streamers buy a show to begin with, they usually want fewer episodes. They don’t want to pony up for, say, 22 episodes if 10 episodes could bring in the same number of subscribers.
WONG: Actually raises production costs because of an accounting principle called amortization.
MULVEY: This is when a business spreads out the cost of a big purchase. Fewer episodes means there’s less room to spread.
SCHUR: In the old days, you would build a set. You would spend $3 million on your set, but you spread that cost out over 22 episodes. Well, it’s not that much per episode to have that set. Now you’re only spreading it over eight episodes.
WONG: So this means that TV studios need to find other ways to make money, one being selling distribution overseas.
SCHUR: The world is now almost completely open, and as a result, the studios need – in order to make the gobs of money they’re trying to make, they have to sell their shows everywhere.
MULVEY: And comedy is cultural.
SCHUR: What is funny in one country is not necessarily funny in another. You know what does travel? Cops chasing bad guys.
WONG: So that is the baseline answer to why we still have a lot of “Law & Order”- or “CSI”-type shows and not a lot of sitcoms.
MULVEY: There’s also a comedy physics problem. Sitcoms often need a few episodes to gel.
WONG: Mike says that the streaming-world system does not give these kinds of comedies the time they need to experiment and find their footing. Audiences move on quickly.
MULVEY: Bottom line, comedies don’t have time to do the research and development they often need to succeed.
SCHUR: That’s the last sort of tragic piece of this, is that this system cuts you off at the knees before you have a chance to have something like “The Office” really click and take off.
MULVEY: We wondered if Mike was an exception. You would think that his track record would make him a pretty good bet for a streamer. He says he has the benefit of the doubt, but he still had to adapt.
WONG: Mike has his black belt in making hangout shows, boring settings with colorful characters that you want to see week after week. But the market has changed.
MULVEY: Ricky Mulvey.
WONG: Wailin Wong, NPR News.
Accuracy and availability of transcripts for NPR programming may vary. Transcript text may also be revised to correct errors or match updates to audio. Audio may be edited after its original broadcast or publication. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
Please note that NPR platforms and products also include some programming produced by third parties; NPR cannot guarantee transcripts for that content and some transcripts may be produced using automated or other tools.