AI influencers promise lower costs and greater control over brand messaging. But will customers trust them? UVA Darden professors Raj Venkatesan and Serena Hagerty explore what marketers should consider before giving a virtual character a voice.
Artificial intelligence is creating two huge shifts for marketers. The first is that AI is becoming a new discovery channel: consumers increasingly ask AI what to buy, rather than relying on classic search like Google. The second is that AI is becoming a new marketing messenger, with many brands now creating their own virtual influencers.
The latter creates a strategic dilemma for marketing teams: stick with the human influencers who have become key to brand building in recent years or complement—even replace—them with AI characters.
According to University of Virginia Darden School of Business Professor Raj Venkatesan, the choice requires marketers to think again about how customers discover their brands, what makes an influencer credible and where AI can strengthen—or undermine—trust.
A case study on Brazilian health food company Mais Mu, co-authored by Venkatesan and Professor Serena Hagerty, offers lessons for marketers pondering whether to stick with human influencers, embrace AI characters or use both.
Mais Mu’s marketing chief Rafael Bertoni wanted to turn the company’s digital mascot, a cartoon cow called MUKA, into an AI influencer. AI promised more control at little cost, but it also risked undermining the authenticity that had been core to the brand’s success.
The Psychology of Influencers
As consumers distance themselves from traditional forms of marketing, brands are increasingly trying to reach them through social media influencers. The shift is significant: The influencer marketing…
Know When the Human Matters
The economics are tempting for Mais Mu and other brands. Virtual influencers can be far cheaper, easier to scale and come with the added benefit of cutting the risk of a human influencer going off script in ways that can damage the brand.
On the other hand, a World Federation of Advertisers survey found 96% of members worried about trust and acceptance with AI influencers, while 73% had concerns about authenticity.
Venkatesan explains that what makes an influencer, human or AI, credible depends on the message they’re spouting. “If the message is about how well a product works, expertise may matter most, which can play well with virtual influencers who can draw on data and offer consistency,” he says.
Hagerty says an advantage of human influencers is that people can develop surprisingly strong bonds with them. “Human influencers are often persuasive because consumers develop such deep parasocial relationships with them—often leading consumers to feel a genuine sense of closeness with the influencer,” she adds.
The big unknown is whether AI can recreate that bond. People are already forming emotional attachments to AI chatbots, Hagerty notes, raising the possibility that consumers could eventually feel similarly toward virtual influencers as they do with human influencers.
Human influencers helped get Mais Mu’s brand off the ground. When Mais Mu began paying influencers, online sales and Instagram growth accelerated sharply.
Any move into AI, therefore, had to add value without destroying what already worked.
Start with the Customer, Not the AI
The idea to use AI influencers started with figuring out who was actually buying Mais Mu’s products. Bertoni surveyed the brand’s most active online buyers and got more than 1,500 responses. Nine out of 10 were women, a quarter were mothers and over half lived with a partner or children.
Mais Mu saw them as the people choosing what the entire family ate. Win them over, and the brand could reach the wider household.
The lesson is that brands need to start with the customer in mind, and then work out where the AI may fit
Build on What Customers Already Love
Bertoni’s idea was to use generative AI to build stories around MUKA. He even imagined a family of cows, with the digital mascot as its matriarch, that could get the whole family talking about Mais Mu.
There was a risk consumers simply would not buy into an AI-made character. The big unknown was whether the company could increase control of the messaging without sacrificing the authenticity that had helped build the brand in the first place.
According to Hagerty, the case points to another choice marketers will have to make: How human should an AI influencer actually sound? More human-like characters may feel more relatable, but if marketers push realism too far, consumers could find them unsettling.
Mais Mu had another option. MUKA was already a cartoon cow, so its AI influencer did not need to pretend to be human.
Venkatesan says the takeaway is to give AI something to work with: “MUKA already had a big following and a place in the brand. AI offered a way to do more with an asset customers already knew.”
Get Ready for AI to Talk to Your Customers
Virtual influencers may prove to be only the start of AI’s role in the customer relationship.
Brazilian retailer Magazine Luiza shows how much further this could go. In 2023, its virtual influencer Lu started using generative AI to talk directly to customers, recommend products based on their questions, create content, and handle everything from stock checks and delivery updates to complaints.
“This shows how a virtual influencer can become something much bigger than a marketing tool. It can become the new interface between a company and its customers,” says Venkatesan.
“Don’t think of AI influencers as just digital celebrities,” Venkatesan says. “They could end up helping customers find products, choose what to buy and sort out problems afterwards. That’s a much bigger deal than who fronts your next campaign.”
Topics
Artificial Intelligence,Marketing & Sales
Story Type
Article
About UVA Darden School of Business
The University of Virginia Darden School of Business prepares responsible global leaders through unparalleled transformational learning experiences.
Darden’s graduate degree programs and Executive Education & Lifelong Learning programs offered by the Darden School Foundation set the stage for a lifetime of career advancement and impact.
Senior Associate Director, Editorial and Media Relations
Rajkumar Venkatesan
Ronald Trzcinski Professor of Business Administration
Venkatesan is an expert in customer relationship management, AI and marketing, marketing metrics and analytics, and mobile marketing. His research focuses on developing customer-centric marketing strategies that provide measurable results.
1 Comment
Pingback: 5 Best TV Shows Like Peacock's Crystal Lake - Comic Vibe