Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards/Mister Fantastic in 20th Century Studios/Marvel Studios’ FANTASTIC FOUR: FIRST STEPS. Photo courtesy of 20th Century Studios/Marvel Studios
The Marvel Universe is lousy with geniuses. Sure, DC has its share of smarties, but the Marvel Universe was born in the atomic age, when optimism for the future and fear of the bomb coalesced in sci-fi stories about brilliant people creating suits of armor, undergoing dangerous experiments, and living in secret technological utopias. In fact, Marvel has so many geniuses that a movie like Spider-Man: Brand New Daycan feature Peter Parker at once broke and working with an advanced technology, and nobody bats an eye.
With so many smart people in the Marvel Universe, we cannot help but do a very dumb thing and try to signal out the 10 smartest. Our evidence will come from examples in the comics (which, as anyone who has read more than three issues knows, can be inconsistent), as well as intuition and preference. Which is a long way of saying that people may disagree with some of these choices. But you know what they say, if you’re so smart, why don’t you make your own list of Marvel geniuses? Or maybe, leave a (nice and respectful) comment below.

Iron Man
Of course, we have to start with Tony Stark, who the MCU has changed from a venerable B-lister to the most recognizable superhero genius. To be sure, Stark was always one of the smartest people in the Marvel Universe, even when he wasn’t so popular. After all, he built a suit of armor in a cave with a box of scraps in both the comics and in the MCU, a concept he continued to iterate upon, leading to the nanobot extremis suits he wears today.
If there’s a shot against Iron Man’s intelligence, it’s that he’s thoroughly an engineer and often lacks other types of smarts. Especially before the first movie, Tony Stark was portrayed as a futurist whose ability to see what’s coming made him either self-destructive or cruel. Even in better moments, such as when he built the Avengers Machine as a mea culpa to Captain Americaduring the run-up to Secret Wars, Tony too often sees people as cogs—cogs that he can arrange into perfect working order, but cogs nonetheless.

Mister Fantastic
Were this a ranked list, Reed Richards a.k.a. Mister Fantastic would be at the very top (albeit with an asterisk). He is undoubtedly the smartest person in the Marvel Universe, at least at this very moment. Sure, others will eventually surpass him, and yes, he did make one very big and notable mistake that would forever change him and his family’s lives. But no one has quite the same level of book knowledge and, just as important, capacity for imagination than Reed Richards, a point made time and again in Fantastic Four comics, including the current incredible run by Ryan North.
The asterisk comes from the fact that some of Mister Fantastic’s intelligence comes from his superpowers. He uses his ability to change shapes to expand his brain and, by extension, his consciousness, allowing for different types of thinking. While that’s not exactly cheating, it does blur the line between a genius and someone like, say, the Kree Supreme Intelligence, who has a computer brain and access to many minds. Still, the fact that Reed was brilliant before exposure to cosmic rays renders those questions moot. And the fact that he manages to best variants like the Maker, who uses further augments, proving that Reed’s smarts aren’t just extensions of his powers.

Doctor Doom
Of course, if Reed makes this list, then his old pal Doctor Doom also has to make it… just one step below. Of course, Doom would disagree, and he has strong evidence to back it up. Doom is, of course, one of Earth’s greatest scientific minds, as demonstrated by the armor he wears and the army of Doombots he commands. He hasn’t quite reached the level of Scientist Supreme, a title enjoyed by others on this list, but he’s been close. He has, however, become Sorcerer Supreme, a reminder that he has mastered the mystic arts as well as the mechanical arts, something no one else on this list can claim.
So why does Doom fall under the hated Richards? Part of the reason is that Doom’s insecurities limit him. He can’t quite get past his own arrogance and need for control, which means that he saddles his own intellect and gives way to rage or pettiness. Also, there was that one time in college that he got a math problem wrong and ended up scarring his face, which isn’t a big deal altogether, but it is always fun to bring up.

Ant-Man
Speaking of people whose personal shortcomings limit their intelligence, we need to talk about Hank Pym. A founding member of the Avengers, Hank Pym created Pym particles, a revolutionary form of comic book science that, a) allows him and other heroes to change their size while retaining their strength and mass, and b) allows writers to wave away any physics problem that would prevent the rule of cool (see also: the unstable molecules invented by Reed Richards). Hank also became Scientist Supreme, thus canonically recognized as the greatest technological mind in the Marvel Universe.
For all that he’s done well, however, Hank never figured out his extreme emotional instability. Even if we remind ourselves that the panel of him slapping his wife Janet Van Dyne was a miscommunication between artist and writer and should be given no more credence than, say, adult Reed Richards dating Sue when she was a teen. But Hank’s mental state (and refusal to address it) means that he wastes a lot of his energy on coming up with new identities and making Ultrons. That last one proved to be a particularly dumb idea.

Amadeus Cho
As much as we rag on Hank, he did get one great moment. In 2009’s Mighty Avengers #21, Hank meets Amadeus Cho, who introduces himself as the seventh-smartest person on the planet. “Really? Well, I’ve been off-planet for a while,” answers Hank, “so you should probably knock yourself down to eighth.” Harsh as it is to be on the receiving end of that burn, eighth smartest person on the planet is pretty good, especially for someone as young as Amadeus Cho.
Created by Greg Pak and Takeshi Miyazawa for 2005’s Amazing Fantasy #15, Amadeus Cho first appeared as a quiz kid whose game show success drew the ire of a supervillain. From that relatively low-stakes beginning, Cho made his way into the world of superheroes, first as a pseudo-sidekick to the Hulk and then especially traveling with Hercules. After concocting for himself a controlled dose of gamma radiation, Cho has become the Totally Awesome Hulk or Brawn, a member of the teen team the Champions. Cho is given to all the same outbursts and errors in judgment that affect any other teen boy. But he can manage his emotions even in Hulk form… so maybe Hank Pym should knock himself down to eighth.

Moon Girl
As with Amadeus Cho, young geniuses are a tricky proposition. Not only do precocious kids make for tedious reading, but they can often hypercharge the power creep that always happens with superhero comics, resulting in characters becoming too perfect, too quickly. Moreover, writers often talk about young geniuses in terms of potential to be realized, not their current state (see: Valeria Richards, who just misses this list).
All of which is to say that Lunella Lafayette a.k.a. Moon Girl belongs on this list precisely for the way she’s largely avoided those problems. Moon Girl is, of course, scientifically brilliant. The 2015 series that first introduced Lunella (by Brandon Montclare, Amy Reeder, and Natacha Bustos) found her making an intergalactic bridge to Kree space, even in elementary school. But the thing that sets Lunella apart is her bond with Devil Dinosaur, matching her scientific mind with an empathetic heart. Young Moon Girl still has a lot to learn, but if she can continue to balance her technical genius with care for others, she may end up the smartest person in the entire Marvel Universe.

Doctor Octopus
At this point, someone might begin to wonder about the absence of our friendly neighborhood Spider-Man, Peter Parker. After all, Pete’s a science whiz who created his web-shooters as a teen in his bedroom, and ran a successful lab and company. Shouldn’t he make the cut? He might, but even more so than Hank Pym or Victor Von Doom, Peter limits himself and rarely exercises his full potential. In fact, the one time he really did go all out, Peter was under the control of someone else, a person who does earn a spot on this list: Doctor Otto Octavius.
Forget your Mad Thinkers, Tinkerers, and Doctors Doom; Doc Ock is the premiere mad scientist in the Marvel Universe. Where emotional and mental shortcomings hamstring so many of the greats, Otto lets his megalomania drive his thirst for intervention, pushing boundaries and exploring dangerous experiments. Doctor Octopus doesn’t even get slowed by set-backs such as fusing arms to his back or death, and instead uses them as opportunities to further iterate. Sure, Otto had to concede that Peter is the superior Spider-Man; but if we’re just talking geniuses, then Octavius gets the edge, at least until Peter Parker gets his act together.

Blue Marvel
Most Marvel geniuses carry echoes of the Kennedy-era optimism that marked the 1960s in which the company debuted. But the concept of super-geniuses goes back far further, including pulp novels about brilliant adventurer Doc Savage, the Man of Bronze. DC has incorporated some of these elements into characters like Superman, but Marvel has largely ignored pulp geniuses, at least until the 2008 series Adam: Legend of the Blue Marvel by Kevin Grevioux and Mat Broome. That story introduced Adam Brashear a.k.a. Blue Marvel, a super-strong hero whose experiments in the Negative Zone gave him anti-matter powers.
Like another 2000s character, the Sentry, Blue Marvel was a late and retconned addition to the Marvel Universe, a Superman-like genius who had operated in the 1960s, but who disappeared from public life after the public learned he was Black. However, since he returned to action, Blue Marvel has established himself as a renaissance man who takes on the galaxy’s most complicated problems. That was especially apparent in the pages of Al Ewing’s Ultimates run, in which Brashear dealt with multiversal threats that would give most geniuses a splitting headache, using both his brains and his brawn.

Black Panther
“But wait,” one may ask. “Isn’t T’Challa’s sister Shuri smarter than him? After all, she’s the one who makes all the inventions.” That’s true, but remember, there are many different types of intelligence. And why Shuri edges out T’Challa in the lab, few people can combine their technical knowhow with both strategic excellence and political wisdom. As a hero, a military leader, and a king, Black Panther Challa must wear multiple hats, giving him one of the most multifaceted minds in the Marvel Universe.
This isn’t to say that T’Challa isn’t subject to the same shortcomings that affect other great Marvel thinkers. His feud with Namor, for example, cost his country more lives than necessary, and many have wondered if his membership in the Avengers doesn’t take attention away from his duties in Wakanda. Yet, even if we allow him the occasional mistake, there’s no question that Black Panther applies his brilliance to more diverse areas than nearly anyone else on the planet.

Mister Sinister
Every person listed here is smart. But how many of them are fun? Even Hank McCoy a.k.a. the Beast, someone who just misses the cutoff line here, seems pretty dour when he’s conducting experiments, unless he’s paling around with Wonder Man. No, if you want to watch a great mind have a good time, then you need to seek out Nathaniel Essex, the mad geneticist who became X-Men villain Mister Sinister.
Born in the mid-19th century, Essex began sympathetically enough, initially plying his genius to discovering a cure to the types of birth defects that killed his young son. However, when he discovered the phenomenon of mutants, Essex went nuts. First, he blended his DNA with that of mutants, giving himself powers. Then he started experimenting in cloning, a practice he continues to this day as the evil Mister Sinister. In fact, when he’s not combining DNA to create wacky mutant hybrids, Sinister is arguing with his clones about who is the real Essex. Who says smart guys can’t be fun?

1 Comment
Pingback: Killproof, The Gun Honey Spin - Comic Vibe