Earth Guide: A Graphic Novel
writer: Ursula K. Le Guin
Adapted by the artist: Fred Fordham
Publisher: Clarion Book
Publication date: March 2025
I’ve been – a little embarrassed – now consumed Ursula K. Le Guin’s Classic 1968 fantasy novel, Earth Guidein 3 1/2 different formats. Of course, I’ve read prose novels and I’ve listened to audiobooks, and recently some are because I want a review. Most importantly, I also saw the worst movies that were arguably Ghibli Studios, Stories from Earthwhich is half the time mentioned above, because it is not an adaptation of the book, although it does have the main character version of the book. All of this is to say, I would love to experience this story in the fourth media comic.
So this year I was able to release Earth Guide Graphic novel, adapted Fred Fordham. I’ve never thought about what this novel looks like as a comic before. For me, Le Guin’s writing really doesn’t need to adapt to other media. Although I am more familiar with her classic science fiction novels Hanish cycle, I think Earth cycle It is a major literary achievement, and it is Le Guin’s famous achievement in language proficiency and thought. And I don’t think any of her works are particularly visual. In fact, one thing I have long admired for Le Guin’s science fiction and fantasy writing is that it is not its description, which gives readers an almost anthropological set of ideas (often deeply rooted in moral or philosophy) and allows them to visualize the world in ways that make the most sense to them.
However, Fordham’s choice complicates this situation. Fordham has previously produced other timeless comics of the perfect prose novel, including Kill an ignorant bird and A brave new world. His work is lush and expressive, and for its visual range, the delightful storytelling choices he manages to convey, deploying the full use of comic storytelling tools, from emotional face portrayals to frames to page layouts. Fordham is the artist behind this book, which transformed me from curiosity to a must-read. If anyone can make it work as a comic, it’s him. I have to see it.
When told through the comics, I found this story absolutely amazing. Earthsea may be perfect for visualization, and nature’s entanglement in this fantasy world is so severe in ways that there is no dominant stage. Earthsea’s name means that it is mainly set on water, islands or archipelagos where the Sparrowhawk adventure takes place. It’s all beautiful for Fordham.
But you can predict a lot of this book. I was surprised at how powerful the visualization of Sparrowhawk and his contemporaries were. As the son of Le Guin, Theo Downes-Le GuinIn the introduction to this book, Sparrowhawk’s notes are often visually regarded as middle-aged white. The book wisely chose the choice that ages him, which emphasizes the powerful young arrogance theme of the story, with innate power but requires the ability to learn to use it responsibly and estimate failure in nuance, which means that people learn a lot from it, even though it costs them a lot. Sparrowhawk also shows darkness in the skin, as a person living in the Sunshine Island community is likely to be.
So, I think these choices do a lot of narrative work in a way that emphasizes the original story, but also set it apart, somewhat specific. Comics have the ability to allow readers to fill in spaces between sequential panels, but the design of the world and the people in it requires consistency. People need to see themselves as heroes, but they need to choose to make a choice about how the hero looks, and Fordham will most certainly do that and do it well.
The traps surrounding this (from magic to the aforementioned natural scenery) are also gorgeous, though in a more predictable way. However, this makes everything equally pleasant. The dragon is huge, sinister, plaguing shadows are sinister and vague, and the scars across Sparrowhawk are terrible, just like adding a stake. It’s all well organized and it’s a real pleasure to taste because of mistakes and the real name is closely protected.
Do Earth Guide Work as a comic? Of course I would say that. I think this is the upper level of (restricted) literature adaptation of comics that I have read, if not totally reaching ridiculous heights Paul Karasik and David Mazzucchelli Having done it while adapting Paul Auster’s New York Trilogy. But this is still an A-level book and an absolute must-read for fans of Le Guin, High Fantasy, or both.
There is now an Earth Wizard
Read more Beat comments!
